"What would government authority be, even with the help of religion, that seducer of souls, if it did not have the yellow of property to seize arms, the capital to credit force? It would be a one-armed despotism, in great danger, at the very moment it would want to show off, of receiving, instead of servile obedience, many blows from the popular John Bull; a purveyor of arbitrary power on the verge of closing shop because of the end of its lease and for lack of consumers willing to swallow its drug."
Unfortunately, the idea of individual property isn't just in the minds of the bourgeoisie; it's also in the minds of the proletariat, and it's so prominent there that poor, sickly people-who don't even have a smock to wear or a piece of bread to eat-cross themselves and cry out against the redistributionists! As if-assuming that communism were about sharing, which it isn't, since it's quite the opposite-there wouldn't be any advantage for them in sharing in a society where they have nothing and others have everything...
However, if the idea of collective ownership is still repugnant to populations atrophied by poverty, there is one thing that repels them at least as much, and that is the exploitation of man by man.
The community, by concentrating the forces and efforts of each individual, the forces and efforts of everything, would make them all converge toward the same goal, toward social economy, and, through unity of property and human solidarity, would ensure to the individual an equal sum of enjoyments, an immense distribution of well-being and freedom; - and allow me a digression about this word: Freedom! which has been so abused against the community and which, it is true, the communists of certain schools have treated with disdain. - In a society of equals, where the sovereign would be called the people, and no longer king or pope, emperor or father, president or servant, dictatorship or delegation, - would not human beings, who all have an instinctive feeling for freedom, and who all desire the integral development of their multifaceted nature, place it at the forefront of needs to be satisfied? - And, to resume my interrupted sentence, - the community, I was saying, where everything belongs to everyone, everyone would be freed from the daily worry of individual provision; delivered from the need to ossify their heart, to dry up their intelligence, to use all their energy to imagine and employ means of production for themselves and of destruction for their fellow human beings, and could then open their brain as well as their soul to thoughts fruitful for all as well as for each individual, where the organization of work attractive by series would have replaced Malthusian competition and repulsive work; the community, splendid ideal, luminous sphere, still blinds, alas! by dazzling them, the masses crouching in the rut of the past under the darkness of ignorance. They see and feel more closely the exploitation which, cigar in mouth, whip in hand, keeps them bent under the weight of labor in the anguish of humiliation and need, while the master, for his part, parades his arrogance and idleness in satisfactions and pleasures.
The right to work-that is what, in the 1848 resolutions , most deeply impressed the proletariat. That is the wedge which, failing subversion, will penetrate the very heart of property ownership and ultimately prevail.
But it is not a matter, as in February , of proclaiming it in principle; it must be decreed materially, solidified, given substance-that is to say, abolishing usury in all its forms: in the form of interest on capital, at any rate whatsoever; in the form of wages, for any work whatsoever; in the form of rent for anything whatsoever, be it housing or land, workshops or tools. Declare the exploitation of man by man a crime and an offense. -Let anyone who owns a house, if he does not live in it alone, be required to give mortgaged shares in it in exchange for quarterly payments. Let anyone who owns land, if he does not cultivate it alone, be required to partner with those who will cultivate it with him. Let anyone who owns a workshop, tools, if he does not occupy it, if he does not operate them alone, be required to partner with those who will work with him. That every parasitic intermediary between producer and consumer be eliminated. That bazaars-communal property, free exchange-replace the shop, a mercantile entity, a usurious business. That, in the new code, theft with a golden key, theft from a property, be equated with theft with false keys, with burglary. That the usurer-under the guise of owner, banker, manufacturer, or merchant-be equated with the common swindler, and branded and punished as such. Finally, that another law of expropriation for reasons of public utility be maintained or enacted, and that all those who leave their houses empty, their lands uncultivated, their equipment unoccupied be expropriated, as is practiced today for a road, a railway, and the means of production or housing be returned to the workers who have requested it.
Here is how expropriation of movable or immovable property could be carried out for reasons of public utility. In each municipality, arbitrators appointed by the people would be tasked with appraising the properties. Once the appraisal was completed, the former owner would receive the amount in bonds secured against the property itself, which would be nothing other than exchange vouchers valid throughout the Republic. As for individuals, men or women, without means of subsistence and without manual labor or employment in the various administrative bodies, they would receive the minimum daily wage, as workers in apprenticeship workshops.
And let there be no mistake. If I propose only a palliative to the scourge of property ownership, it is not because that is all I desire. The goal, I have said, is collective ownership, common possession. But, given the sovereignty of the people, and since nothing is possible except what the people will; convinced, moreover, that it would be neither in the will nor the power of any dictatorship to do them violence in this matter, I bow to their preconception, forced and constrained as I am, by proposing only the redemption of property instead of outright expropriation.
And, this proposal, which aims at the abolition of private property by eliminating the exploitation of labor by capital, would be voted for wholeheartedly by the proletarians most swaddled in the routine of the past.
Capital! Octopus of gigantic proportions, whose sucking membranes are the leeches of exploitation; horrible mollusk of the ocean of labor, which, like the other with its venom, muddles the flow of production with your gold, you who, attaching yourself to the virile parts of humanity, to all that gives birth through labor, suck and pump from it through every pore the blood of its veins and the marrow of its bones; - monster of nervous plunder, your hour has also struck on the dial of public condemnation, and you will not escape the harpoon of the right to work! May the personal property that vomited you forth not one day escape the same fate, and may humanity soon bathe freely in the blue waves of the community!»
Joseph Déjacque , in The Revolutionary Question (1854)
https://www.socialisme-libertaire.fr/2026/10/joseph-dejacque-de-la-propriete.html
_________________________________________
Source: A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Geen opmerkingen:
Een reactie posten