SPREAD THE INFORMATION

Any information or special reports about various countries may be published with photos/videos on the world blog with bold legit source. All languages ​​are welcome. Mail to lucschrijvers@hotmail.com.

Search for an article in this Worldwide information blog

zondag 22 november 2026

WORLD WORLDWIDE EUROPE SPAIN MADRID - news journal UPDATE - (en) Spain, Regeneracion: The Liberal Capture of Anarchism (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

We are reproducing an article from *The Polar Bl@st*-an anarcho-communist portal based in Aotearoa/New Zealand-originally published on November 22, 2025: "The Liberal Capture of Anarchism." Translated for *Regeneración Libertaria*.

Table of Contents
1. From the Struggle to the Office: How Dependency Is Manufactured
2. Voting as a Symptom
3. The Most Dangerous Capitulation: Abandoning Antimilitarism
4. Aotearoa: The Treaty, Biculturalism, and NGOs
5. What Must Be Reaffirmed to Break Free from This Capture

In recent years, a peculiar trend has emerged within parts of the anarchist milieu-particularly among those sectors closest to academia, the NGO apparatus, and the broad "social justice" ecosystems of the liberal left. It essentially argues that "we are not living in revolutionary times." This statement is always delivered with a tone of weary resignation, as if the person speaking has become too sophisticated, too worldly, too traumatized, or too professionalized to continue believing in the old principles.

We are told that anarchists cannot reject electoralism because it would be "dogmatic" or "purist." That we cannot maintain principled antimilitarism in the face of imperial alignments and geopolitical chessboards because it would be "naive," "privileged," or simply "not how the world works." That we cannot question nationalism because, apparently, even anarchists must kneel before the altar of flags when the appropriate war breaks out. And in Aotearoa, we are increasingly told that anarchists-anarchists of all people-should align themselves with the Labour Party, the Greens, or Te Pati Maori, and that any other stance amounts to supporting the right, favoring fascism, or failing to take "real-world consequences" seriously.

It is a remarkable ideological contortion that has transformed many self-proclaimed anarchists into appendages of liberalism, junior partners of the parliamentary left, and, in some cases, vocal defenders of state military power. This collapse is not merely a political drift; it is a profound renunciation of the most basic principles of anarchism. It is a capitulation disguised as realism, a surrender dressed in nuance, and a fear of becoming politically inconvenient repackaged as maturity.

But, at its core, this discourse expresses something simple and corrosive: the belief that anarchism is incapable of acting on its own as a revolutionary force and that, therefore, it must delegate its capacity for action to liberal institutions.

From the front lines to the office: how dependency is manufactured
The current collapse of anarchist independence cannot be understood without understanding the cultural ecosystem that now inhabits much of the left. In Aotearoa, as throughout the Western world, political energy has been systematically channeled into NGOs, consultancies, academic departments, and publicly funded "progressive" institutions that operate comfortably within the infrastructure of capitalism. These spaces speak the language of radicalism, but behave according to the incentives of the bureaucracy.

Many young anarchists no longer radicalize through struggle, occupations, workplace organizing, antimilitarist resistance, housing battles, or actions against the police. Instead, they socialize within a professional sphere where the primary goal is securing contracts, maintaining social capital, and avoiding political risks. The result is predictable: anarchism becomes a mere brand image rather than a commitment to revolutionary action.

Within these institutional spaces, rejecting electoralism is portrayed as childish. Criticizing left-wing parties is presented as sabotaging "progress." Maintaining antimilitarist principles is presented as dangerous idealism. Refusing to join the Labor-Green-Te Pati Maori electoral bloc is seen as betraying the "community."

But these aren't moral judgments; they're calculations of job security. Anarchists working in NGO networks and academia quickly internalize that their material survival depends on aligning themselves with the consensus of the soft left. Criticizing electoralism jeopardizes contracts. Antimilitarism damages their reputation. Anti-state politics complicates relationships with their funders.

Thus a new rule is imposed: anarchists should avoid being too anarchist. Radical rhetoric is permitted, and even encouraged, as long as it ultimately strengthens the parliamentary left. Anything that threatens the state's monopoly on legitimacy becomes taboo.

The result is an anarchism that speaks fluently of "mutual aid" but forgets that mutual aid is not a social service, but a weapon against the myth that the state is necessary. An anarchism that condemns racism and colonialism but channels all resistance toward institutions aligned with the state. An anarchism that advocates decolonization but backs down from any challenge to parliamentary authority in Aotearoa. An anarchism that supports struggles abroad only when they fit Western strategic narratives.

In essence, it is an anarchism that has lost its way and then rationalizes that loss as intellectual sophistication.

Voting as a symptom
The drift towards electoral reasoning is a key symptom of this collapse. It takes several forms.

Sometimes it's explicit: "We must vote for Labour, the Greens, or TPM to keep the right out." Other times it's disguised with social justice rhetoric: "Marginalized communities suffer when the right wins, therefore anarchists have a responsibility to vote." Sometimes it's wrapped in strategic fatalism: "Voting won't save us, but it helps buy us time."

But underlying all of this is the same central assumption: that the State must remain the primary vehicle for social change and that anarchists must adjust their politics to this supposed reality.

It is extraordinary how quickly we forget that the modern state, whether liberal or conservative, is structurally incapable of abolishing the exploitation, hierarchies, and coercive apparatus that define it. Even when left-wing governments attempt reforms, they do so by strengthening the very machinery that anarchists want to dismantle: police, prisons, militaries, borders, welfare bureaucracies, surveillance technologies, and tax collection systems.

In Aotearoa, the Labour Party is a textbook example. Every time it returns to power, the anarchist movement fractures. Those closest to NGO infrastructure begin to advocate for strategic support. The rhetoric of "harm reduction" is used as a weapon to silence the criticisms of those who rightly point out that the Labour Party has proven to be a reliable servant of capital, imperial alliances, and domestic managerialism.

This dynamic intensified during the Ardern era[Translator's note: Jacinda Ardern was Prime Minister of New Zealand from 2017 to 2023 and leader of the Labour Party, with a progressive agenda]. Many anarchists who had previously ridiculed parliamentarians were reduced to timid criticism or outright silence, because the social atmosphere of liberal worship made genuine dissent a cultural taboo. In activist circles, Ardernism was treated as "good enough," and dissenters were labeled troublemakers, misogynists, or unrealistic purists.

A movement that claims to be revolutionary should never be so fragile. However, the collapse was widespread and revealing: many anarchists were more committed to social belonging to the liberal cultural class than to anarchism itself.

Once this cultural shift occurs, a fatal logic takes hold: anarchists must not reject electoralism because their allies, who are often their employers, depend on it. This is how a revolutionary tradition becomes a pressure group.

The most dangerous capitulation: abandoning antimilitarism
The most alarming expression of this drift has been the abandonment of anarchist antimilitarism. For over a century, anarchists have insisted that war is not an aberration, but a predictable outcome of the capitalist state system. Militarism is the purest expression of hierarchical power, resource extraction, nationalism, and obedience. It is the machine that devours working-class youth to protect the interests of warring ruling classes.

However, in recent years, many self-proclaimed anarchists have adopted a military logic indistinguishable from Western liberalism. They encourage NATO when it suits them. They speak approvingly of sending arms to conflicts between major powers. They amplify the language of "defense," "security," and "strategic necessity." They shame antimilitarists for "not supporting the right side."

This is the most dangerous capitulation of all.

Once anarchists accept the legitimacy of war, they relinquish their last significant distinction from the statist left. The result is an anarchism that obediently follows the emotional rhythms of the Western media-outraged when instructed, supportive when instructed, silent when instructed-instead of maintaining its own antimilitarist compass.

Part of this collapse is ideological. Part of it is material. But a significant part is psychological. Many anarchists today are terrified at the idea of being seen as "irresponsible." Liberal-leftist culture frames politics through the lens of compliance, safety, and harm reduction. Anything that challenges institutional frameworks is considered reckless. Anything that disrupts political normality is dangerous. Anything that undermines the parliamentary left is "indirectly helping the right."

This creates a paralyzing moral landscape where the worst sin an anarchist can commit is not to support the status quo enthusiastically enough. The fear of being blamed for a right-wing victory becomes so overwhelming that many stop imagining politics beyond the narrow electoral horizon. The fear of being accused of "not caring" about marginalized communities becomes a weapon to silence radical politics.

In such a climate, anarchism becomes an identity, not a praxis: a way of feeling radical while acting safely.

This anxiety-based policy produces an anarchist who:

He privately accepts that the State cannot free anyone, but is afraid to say so publicly;
Privately he knows that elections don't change anything fundamental, but he votes and pressures others to do the same;
In private he opposes the war, but he repeats liberal arguments so as not to appear insensitive;
Privately he wants to confront capitalism directly, but he settles for symbolic actions within the system.
The result is tragic: anarchists who are radical everywhere except where it matters.

Aotearoa: Treaty, biculturalism and NGOs
The situation in Aotearoa intensifies this collapse because the liberal left is structured around moral frameworks linked to biculturalism, the Treaty discourse[Translator's note: the Treaty of Waitangi, of 1840, between the British Crown and Maori chiefs, central to the debate on decolonization], and NGO-based social justice work. These are important battlegrounds, but the state has learned to use them to maintain its legitimacy.

This produces a political landscape where anarchists are pressured to treat parliamentary actors-especially the Labour Party, the Greens, and Te Pati Maori-as central vehicles of "progress," even when their history is deeply entangled with colonial administration, policing, market capitalism, and militarized foreign policy.

The liberal state in Aotearoa has become adept at portraying moral virtue while intensifying its structural violence. It uses Maori kupu -words in the Maori language-in its image-washing while expanding prisons. It funds "community providers" while crushing the living standards of the working class. It hires iwi consultants -from Maori tribes-while promoting militarized surveillance in the Pacific. It offers symbolic recognition while avoiding material decolonization.

However, many anarchists, immersed in NGO environments and workshops on the Treaty, find it difficult to criticize this dynamic without being accused of cultural ignorance or reactionary politics. The result is silence, caution, or apologetics-behaviors entirely incompatible with the anarchist commitment to confront state power, all state power, regardless of the rhetoric it employs.

And so the argument returns: anarchists must support left-wing parties; anarchists must not reject electoralism; anarchists must not oppose nationalist or militarized frameworks when they present themselves as protectors of indigenous sovereignty or marginalized communities.

Such reasoning confuses the State with the people, an error that anarchists have been warning against for 150 years.

The assertion that anarchists "cannot" reject electoralism, or "cannot" oppose left-wing parties, is ultimately a statement about the impossibility of political imagination. It presupposes that the state is the only available terrain, that nothing meaningful can be done outside of it, and that anarchists must align themselves with the managerial left because the alternative is irrelevance.

But this is only true if we accept the premises of liberal fatalism. The entire anarchist tradition exists because previous generations rejected those premises. Emma Goldman, at the beginning of the 20th century, did not one day decide that anarchists should support progressive mayors. Kropotkin did not conclude that the working class should vote for liberal reformers. The Maori radicals of the 1970s did not decide that liberation came through Parliament. The Spanish CNT did not believe that emancipation required alliances with bourgeois parties[Editor's note: we qualify this statement by the author: the CNT collaborated with the Republican government and the Generalitat in 1936-1937, a participation that organized anarchism has harshly criticized as an abandonment of its principles].

Anarchism has always insisted that politics extends far beyond electoral cycles. If anything, the crises of our era-climate collapse, the housing crisis, imperial military alignments, the breakdown of social infrastructure-demonstrate that anarchist organization is not only viable, but necessary.

The state is not the only arena for political action. Nor is it even the most effective. It is simply the only one that liberals can imagine.

What to reaffirm to escape capture
If anarchism is to recover from liberal capture, it must reaffirm some basic and uncompromising truths.

Anarchists must reject electoralism, not because elections are morally impure, but because electoral participation actively undermines the development of the autonomous power of the working class. Every hour spent campaigning is an hour not spent organizing. Every discussion about strategic voting distracts from the real work of building alternatives. Every second spent defending left-wing parties normalizes the idea that liberation flows from the top down, from Parliament, rather than from the bottom up, from the struggle.

Anarchists must oppose all militarism, not selectively, not only when it fits Western interests, not only when liberals approve of it, because every war strengthens the state, intensifies nationalism, and expands the repressive apparatus that will ultimately be used against us.

Anarchists must reject the notion that left-wing parties represent "the community." The Labour Party does not represent the workers. The Greens do not represent ecological resistance. Te Pati Maori does not represent decolonization. Parties represent themselves: their leadership, their funders, their institutional incentives, their career aspirations.

Anarchists must reject the liberal politics of blame, the idea that we are responsible for right-wing victories if we refuse to align ourselves with the parliamentary left. This logic is emotional blackmail used to discipline dissent.

Most importantly, anarchists must rediscover the belief that we can act, organize, and build political power outside the state. We must stop believing that autonomy is impossible. The future belongs not to voters, but to those who take the risk of creating something outside the suffocating framework of capitalist governance.

The liberal discourse that infects contemporary anarchism ultimately boils down to one pathetic phrase:

"Anarchism can't do anything, so anarchists should help liberals."

It is a defeatist creed disguised as pragmatism. It is the whisper of a movement that has lost faith in itself. It is the ideology of an anarchism that has forgotten its own history, its own victories, its own capacity to terrify the powerful.

When anarchists argue that they cannot reject electoralism, they are abandoning the principle that liberation grows from below. When they argue that they cannot oppose left-wing parties, they are surrendering their independence to the very institutions designed to neutralize social movements. When they argue that they cannot maintain antimilitarism, they are accepting the logic of empire. When they argue that they cannot act without the permission of the state, they are no longer anarchists at all.

We are at a moment when capitalism is crumbling, the climate is collapsing, global militarism is accelerating, and old political categories are breaking down. This is not a time to retreat to the exhausted pragmatism of the liberal left. It is a time to reclaim the boldness and clarity of anarchism: the belief that the working class can organize itself, that communities can govern themselves, that solidarity can replace coercion, and that states-all states-are obstacles to freedom, not vehicles for it.

We owe the world something better than becoming the auxiliary wing of liberalism.

https://regeneracionlibertaria.org/2026/10/20/la-captura-liberal-del-anarquismo/
_________________________________________

Source: A-infos-en@ainfos.ca

Geen opmerkingen:

Een reactie posten