Resistance to Franco's coup gave rise to one of the richest self-governance processes with anarchist protagonism, but weaknesses in the movement led to its defeat. ---- Ninety years ago, one of the most significant revolutionary processes in European territory took place: the Spanish Revolution (1936-37), in the context of the Civil War, which ended with the victory of the coup leaders and the beginning of Francisco Franco's dictatorship in April 1939. Beyond the anniversary, those events left important lessons for future anarchist movements and organizations and a strong influence on subsequent historical and popular events.
Although it began as an immediate response to the Francoist coup in July 1936, the articulations for the implementation of the self-management regime have deep historical origins, in a long construction of Spanish anarchism throughout the social fabric, figuring as a strong popular movement from the end of the 19th century until the founding of the Confederación Nacional del Trabajo , the legendary CNT, in 1910. This entity would become one of the main Spanish political forces, articulating unions not only for the direct struggle for improvements for workers, but also weaving the embryos of a new libertarian social logic, independent of state institutions.
Trade unions housed training schools - the lyceums - that taught anarchist theory and provided basic education to large sectors of the proletariat without access to public education, inspired by the pedagogue Francisco Ferrer and his rationalist school . There were vocational courses for the unemployed, scholarships, and mutual material support for marginalized people. This practice was later dubbed libertarian culture , in accordance with the concept of anarcho-syndicalism , characteristic of the ideology in Spanish territory.
During the dictatorship of Primo de Rivera (1923-1930), the accumulation of experience, the effervescence of debates, and the repressive political situation of leftist organizations in the country fueled the need to found a political organization: the Federación Anarquista Ibérica (FAI), created by exiles in France in 1927, bringing together militants who were already acting as armed militias to confront the regime, around their own program.
CNT divided
Following the victory of the Second Republic in April 1931, the CNT - by then the largest trade union force in the country, with approximately 1.5 million members - held the Madrid Congress. This event marked the formation of two internal currents: the Treintistas , a minority sector supported by an older membership, inclined towards grassroots building, strengthening unions, and structuring the central organization, and which had been the majority since 1910 but carried some reformist leanings; and the aforementioned FAI, with a younger and more precarious base, which emphasized the immediate need for the radicalization of the central organization and the use of its trade union forces to implement libertarian communism in the territories where it had the greatest influence, especially in industrial cities like Barcelona and Zaragoza. This second current was victorious and began to politically lead the CNT.
The FAI's trajectory leading the CNT was marked by three attempts to implement libertarian communism (Figols, 1932; Valencia and Aragon, 1933; Aragon and La Rioja, also in 1933) among the most precarious - and therefore most radicalized - workers, especially in construction. The results substantiated the criticisms made by their anarchist adversaries: the lack of internal coordination among the unions isolated these attempts, facilitating repression, with hundreds of arrests, dozens of deaths, and the persecution of various unions, in addition to reducing the willingness of the rank and file. However, it is during this period that the Confederal Defense Committees and the Economic Defense Committees, CDCs and CDEs, were established. These bodies created a structure of mutual support between unemployed workers and unions in various ways: workshops for the construction and handling of firearms; encouragement of the participation of marginalized individuals in direct actions of assaulting shipments of industrial products (in a context of widespread high cost of living); Direct, violent, and collective actions against abusive rents, layoffs, situations of hyper-exploitation of labor, etc. These popular institutions were the embryos of the anti-fascist militias in 1936.
The following years, known as the "black biennium" (1934-35), were marked by the far-right government and a significant decline in revolutionary forces, with the Asturian Commune (1934) being the only exception. This commune was even boycotted by sectors of the FAI (Italian Armed Forces), receiving support only from local CNT (National Confederation of Labour) unions. The positive effect of this period on the labor movement was the radicalization of the rank and file, which, following the victory of the Popular Front in February 1936, led to the expropriation of large estates and more organized strikes than at the beginning of the decade.
In July, the CNT-FAI leadership carried out an assault on a shipment of weapons arriving from abroad, distributed them to their bases, and, with far greater force and coordination than before, defeated the Guardia Civil and the Mossos d'Esquadra , taking control of the city of Barcelona and extending public self-management of the most important industrial, agricultural, transport, and communications sectors to the interior of Catalonia, Aragon, Andalusia, Castile, and other regions under their influence. This included the important coordination of Telefónica workers , who occupied the main transmission tower to coordinate the revolutionary offensive with various sectors of the country.
Revolution and internal problems
The initial victory over the Francoists and the implementation of workers' self-management in half of Spanish territory generated great enthusiasm, but quickly exposed the movement's main weakness: improvisation in the face of a lack of a political program to replace the recently defeated Republican state management with a coordination that could address the national question of the Civil War. There were various actors operating in the country's geopolitical theater, both internally and externally, for which the anarchist leaders were unprepared. Although some external obstacles to the movement persisted - international relations with liberal nations that could block the supply of foreign products; the intervention of Nazism and Fascism at their peak, with massive support of weapons and money for the Francoists; Francoist control over the colonies with massive troop supplies; the counter-revolutionary intervention of the USSR, etc. - internal problems had a decisive weight.
The anarchists confused political power with state power, denying themselves the political management of public power that they could have assumed. The improvised result was the creation of the Central Committee of Anti-Fascist Militias (CCMA), which operated at a level below the political power that was gradually reactivated by the moribund bourgeois sectors in July, but already recovered in October and fully active in November of that same year, occupying the main ministries: Economy and War. Furthermore, the union and popular bases, which had direct access to the organization of the economic life of the territories liberated by the armed revolution, had no access to decision-making spaces and were not nationally articulated by the CNT beyond control over internal economic articulations. In other words, even with popular control of production and distribution, services, culture, and communication within the liberated territory, macro politics remained under the control of bourgeois republican sectors, with secondary participation from the FAI leadership and even from the Treintistas.
May 1937
The revolutionary process had a profound impact on the rank and file, who actively participated in building the new self-managed social fabric throughout the second half of 1936, while the leadership acted in the opposite direction, assuming political positions within the same bourgeois republican logic they had previously attacked. The most dramatic event of this phenomenon occurred in May 1937, considered by many to be the final event of the anarchist revolution: the disarmament of the popular militias, ten months after the revolution began. There was resistance from grassroots sectors, such as the famous Friends of Durruti, for example, but the process ended with Soviet politics infiltrating the CCMA and returning control of the main institutions to the bourgeois republican sectors, reactivating the bourgeois state.
Strategic issues arose: a) faced with the debate about the need for a centrally commanded army to confront the strong fascist troops, the effectively active military force consisted of spontaneously formed popular militias which, in addition to being undisciplined, had autonomous and regional organization, especially where the CNT (National Confederation of Transport) was poorly articulated with regional unions; b) the lack of a strategy for the monetary issue: the banks, once the target of various direct actions by anarchists, were not expropriated, facilitating the flight of capital abroad, easily sent to the USSR for the purchase of weapons that rarely reached the militias, but always the republican sectors; c) communities liberated by the Revolution confused self-management with "isolationist autonomism" (as was the case in almost all of Andalusia, which, by not submitting to collective, i.e., confederal, decisions, was quickly defeated by the coup plotters); d) The same "autonomism" was observed in the agricultural sector, as it allowed for a plurality of forms of organization of the liberated territories; that is, there were territories that fully collectivized production, but there were also those that allowed the survival of smallholdings, fertile ground for Stalinism to stimulate competition between them and the - economically much more developed - total collectivizations, gaining rapid affiliations to the Spanish Communist Party, which was insignificant before July 1936; e) The independence of class and of state institutions, conveyed for decades by the militancy, did not produce a sufficiently strong political power capable of confronting all sectors of the "counter-revolution," not only the most direct enemy, Francoism supported by Nazism-Fascism, but also the republican sectors supported by the Soviets.
The Spanish experience is contradictory, like all revolutionary processes, but it bequeathed important lessons to new generations of anarchist militants: the vital need for a power project, parallel and independent of the State, but which exerts a political advance beyond the construction of a self-managed structure restricted to the economic and cultural field; even though the Treintistas capitulated to the interventionist model of unions, their observations regarding the strengthening of the confederation through industry and factory committees were lacking in the post-revolutionary moment, since the CNT leadership sought to strengthen the confederation during the unfolding of events, but did not have the same commitment during the years of preparation. On the other hand, the proactive approach of Spanish anarchism, in the sense of creating its own cultural, social, and economic institutions, was decisive for the anarchist project of socialism, the so-called libertarian communism. Let us continue with these reflections towards the construction of Self-Managed Popular Power!
https://socialismolibertario.net/os-90-anos-da-revolucao-espanhola-e-as-licoes-do-processo/
_________________________________________
Source: A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Geen opmerkingen:
Een reactie posten