At the OCL meetings this summer, a discussion was organized, based on
the presentation of the brochure "Souffleur sur les braises" on the
revolts following the death of Nahel, in Nanterre last summer. ---- This
brochure gives the floor to 5 people who live in Hérouville, a suburb of
Caen, and participated in the fiery nights of their neighborhood. Some
people were known for a long time, or crossed paths in the Yellow Vests
(GJ) or more recent struggles, others were unknown before this meeting.
The desire was to show solidarity and undo the distance between the
revolutionary movements and these revolts.
Nahel, a 17-year-old, was killed by a police officer in Nanterre on June
27, 2023, the day after riots broke out in Nanterre, then the day after
that everywhere in France. The comparison with 2005 does not seem
relevant to the authors of the brochure, because at the time the revolt
was confined to the suburbs of large cities and especially in the Paris
region. In 2023, riots broke out in small towns of 4/5000 inhabitants,
where police stations were attacked with Molotov cocktails, tobacco
shops looted, cars burned. A generalized revolt that lasted 5/6 nights,
with attacks by cops using mortars, damage to public buildings or banks,
looting of stores, often with redistribution to the population, as
happened in Caen in 3 working-class neighborhoods.
The Ministry of the Interior counts 23,878 fires, 12,000 vehicles set on
fire, 2,500 public buildings damaged including 273 police and
gendarmerie premises, 105 town halls, 168 schools. The Medef speaks of a
billion euros of deficit for companies following the damage. By
comparison, during the movement against the pension reform which lasted
several weeks, there were 299 attacks against public institutions. This
shows the degree of intensity of these few nights of revolts and
everywhere in France.
Why did it explode this time?
Indeed, this is not the first time that a young person has been shot by
the police and the reactions are rarely of such magnitude. There are at
least 3 elements that can explain these riots. First, a saturation
effect due to the increase in the number of people injured or killed by
gunfire since the 2017 laws that give cops more possibilities to shoot,
then the very shocking video of Nahel's death that circulated very
quickly on social networks and finally references to the film Athena
(1), "we do like Athena!" shouted the rioters.
The organization was done in small groups with young people aged 13/14,
the older ones came to support them. They also dropped them off by car
in other places in the city, so that it would be faster. The
interviewees are 20/25 and are clearly among the oldest. As an anecdote,
two 50-year-old friends who wanted to participate were accosted and
searched by the young people, who did not know them and suspected them
of being cops. A whole neighborhood solidarity was set up, with the
older brothers, the families who reported where the cops were and left
the doors of the buildings open so that the young people could take
shelter. Links between the neighborhoods that are usually opposed, made
it possible to start all at the same time and thus disperse the cops,
but also to exchange information on the cops and for the mortars. The
mortars were brought back from Poland and Germany by go-fasts like the
dealer, and then distributed in the different neighborhoods.
From the start, a call was made: "we don't touch people's vehicles, but
public things". The targets were surveillance cameras, streetlights to
avoid being spotted, schools, town halls, bus and tram companies,
shopping centers on the edge of neighborhoods, tobacconists (436 in
France), sports shops, banks. In Hérouville, there weren't enough cops,
about thirty, and they could only hold the central square, where there
are shops, a theater, and also a market square. At one point, the cops
left, telling the young people, "you're burning down your neighborhood
anyway, we don't care". As soon as they left, the young people attacked
the bank and managed to get in. The cops came back immediately and
charged, there was no question of letting them touch the banks.
In Hérouville, as everywhere, the repression caused a lot of injuries
from flashballs and stun grenades, there were at least 3 arrests. It was
the first time that the GIGN was present, as well as many drones. In
France, there were 1,300 arrests, followed by 762 convictions to a firm
sentence, on average 8 months of incarceration. The GIGN and sometimes
the RAID intervened everywhere in France and drones were widely used.
Curfews were introduced, in Caen buses and trams stopped their service
from 7 p.m. and gas stations also closed at 7 p.m.
The Yellow Vests of Caen were for many people from working class
neighborhoods. From this movement, there remain in Hérouville informal
collectives, for example a garden at the foot of the towers where there
are aperitifs, food recovery and solidarity. Since the riots, 4 cameras
planted at the top of the towers, monitor the garden permanently.
There were attempts by activists to make connections in a more or less
clumsy way. A demonstration was called in the city center, many people
from the neighborhoods came. The people who called for the demonstration
took the lead of the procession with somewhat angry slogans: "we're
going to smash everything, we're going to do our shopping". By saying
we're going to do our shopping, they announce we're going to loot and in
fact they don't do it. The people from the neighborhoods who have been
looting for several nights are disgusted and announce that they won't
come back. At the next demonstration, there will only be 50 people. They
weren't given the lead of the procession, nor the megaphones, and in
addition 4 people were arrested, they were a bit bitter. They feel more
vulnerable in the city center and don't know where to hide unlike in the
neighborhood. The left-wing organizations organized a solidarity
demonstration in September in Caen. She leaves from the only
working-class neighborhood where nothing happened at the end of June,
pure coincidence?
If it only lasted a few nights and if some places were not attacked, it
is probably so as not to disturb business. This is a reality of the
neighborhoods that the struggles are confronted with. It is also due to
the lack of mortars that were used to keep the cops at a distance, and
also of course because of the repression. People died during these
riots, including one in Marseille from a flashball shot at point-blank
range.
We have every interest in getting closer to the people who revolted
because they are cool, even if there are lots of contradictions.
In other cities
In Reims , a city of 220,000 inhabitants, in a district of 30,000
inhabitants, average income 890 euros, 37% of unemployed under 25s, 27%
of single-parent families, priority district of the city, there is a
small tradition of riots, notably during the acquittal of a baker from
the FN who had killed a young man who had stolen croissants from her.
These are the images we see at the beginning of the film "La haine".
Last year, there were 2 days of riots, with very young participants and
adults who followed them, without being masked, and sometimes regulated,
preventing them from attacking certain places, such as the Post Office
where they receive their RSA. A store was targeted, but not the one run
by the Chechens, nor the Kabyles' tobacco shop where the old men play
PMU. The police station, which is empty at night, was attacked, but not
the national police academy or the CRS barracks near the neighborhood.
Contacts were made via Snapchat or Instagram loops, already created at
the high school or elsewhere. The looting is anecdotal: coke, Yop,
sweets, and the next morning the mothers came to stock up on the
groceries necessary for survival, then later it was the alcohol that was
stolen. The HLM office was attacked, we don't know by whom, but
certainly not by the kids. The police remained very discreet, no major
clashes as long as it remained in the neighborhood. On the other hand,
roadblocks were set up in the city center to prevent people from going
there.
In the 93 , the riots were less significant than in 2005. Some things
are surprising. In Bobigny, for example, the looting was more of their
mother's shopping. Rosny 2, the largest shopping center in the 93, was
apparently looted by young people from residential areas. The darons who
protect certain buildings already existed in 2005, but it was more
organized in 2023. In Blanc-Mesnil, mothers had meals in front of the
municipal swimming pool to protect it. Everything was burning around it,
but the general high school, which has a glass facade and would have
been an easy target, was not hit, the vocational high school was. The
silent march for Nahel's death in the city center of Nanterre attracted
an impressive crowd, very calm and family-oriented. It degenerated as
they approached the prefecture, surely by provocation from the many
police officers, to prevent Nahel's family from speaking out.
Mantes la Jolie , 40,000 inhabitants, is known because it is where the
151 high school students were forced to stay on their knees, hands on
their heads, while they blocked their high school to oppose the reform
of the baccalaureate and Parcoursup, but also in support of the Yellow
Vests. There was little solidarity for these high school students,
despite the collective for the defense of young people from Mantois that
was created on this occasion, 150 people at the demonstrations, mainly
the left and the far left. The situation was identical in June, just a
demonstration of 30 people called by Solidaires where there were twice
as many cops. An attempt to create union solidarity, by explaining that
the rioters do not come out anywhere, that they are from our class, the
children of our friends, of our colleagues, remained very much in the
minority. On the possibility of getting involved, same thing as in Caen
when you are over 30, it leaves a feeling of unease. There are very few
political forces left in the neighborhoods. The MIB (2) or the
collective against double punishment, which could, in their time,
provide a link between political forces and the inhabitants of
working-class neighborhoods, no longer exist.
In Toulouse , we quickly realized that the neighborhoods were already
structured into teams, and that there was no place to join them, unlike
the GJ where you could join a roundabout. So, we wanted to do public and
reachable things, with the idea of extending the fight, taking it out of
the ghetto, multiplying the offensives, this resulted in a demonstration
of 400 activists completely supervised by the cops. We would have done
better to do things on our own, block things. We must stop asking
ourselves the question of the outside or even of solidarity, but rather
that of how we get into the fight and not how we support. It is
certainly easier to do anti-repression than to get involved.
There were agreements with the dealers not to start the riots too early,
so that they could sell. We also saw people patrolling the neighborhoods
to watch their cars.
In the 92 in Chatenay Malabry , the Butte Rouge is a very important 100%
HLM city, with projects for rehabilitation, destruction, privatization.
There were no riots in 2005, but there, the annex town hall burned and
the tramway - an important element of gentrification to bring more
affluent people to the city - was damaged. In the 1970s, there were lots
of associations, the Fasti, the Gisti (3) ..., a MJC managed by the
inhabitants and the Communist Party. Now there is nothing left, the
opposition is 20 people in a city of 35,000 inhabitants. There is no
political life, but clientelism with gentrification and the urban
planning where everyone is gorging themselves. When we created a
collective to resist the reconstructions in the Butte Rouge
neighborhood, we couldn't get a room, or at the last minute. The posters
were taken down the same day. People are afraid that they won't be given
housing or that they'll be evicted, so they don't resist much. And the
mayors are going to have even more power to allocate social housing. The
associations are hyper legalistic. To buy social peace, all the
communities have their own room and subsidies. These 40 years of
depoliticizing the neighborhoods explain why things are going to
explode. In 2005, we won, what, a police station in the center of the
neighborhood.
On the issue of the presence of girls and women in the riots
In the Yellow Vests, women were very present and it lasted for more than
a year with a lot of discussions. What about these riots? For some, it
is a spontaneous revolt of anger by people who are used to occupying the
streets, who find it legitimate to do so. For others, girls are less
present than guys in the riots, but it is no different from what happens
elsewhere. Guys have a strong feeling of anger, because they are the
ones who are always arrested and hassled by the police.
There were young and older women in the demonstrations. In Hérouville,
women and children walked around the neighborhood to watch the cops and
protect from afar.
In Rennes, girls were discussing how to make Molotov cocktails with
tampons. They were taking part in looting stores. The rioters were quite
young, and there is repression within the family. Who lets their
daughters out at night? And that is not the same as saying that the
street was forbidden to girls.
The repression
We see that the Senate was expecting a revolt, thanks to the
surveillance of social networks, but not who, where and how. We find a
lot of interesting information on the Senate Information Mission. It
notes at least one incident in 330 cities, including cities that have
never seen this kind of riots like Vierzon. In Montargis people went to
destroy the city center. Those who are convicted are first-time
offenders with an average age of 14, the youngest is 12 years old for a
firm sentence.
In Reims, there were convictions in immediate appearance and probably
bans from the territory for some of the accused who were not seen again
in the neighborhood. There was no solidarity from the left or the far
left, no follow-up of the trials. The residents of the neighborhood were
punished collectively, no public transport for 6 weeks, the renovation
of the bus shelters took more than 4 months. The mayor of Reims proposed
to punish the parents of the rioters by depriving them of social housing
and family allowances.
All the inhabitants of the 93 have suffered collective punishment: no
more buses throughout the department from 9 p.m. and then 7 p.m. The
festivities normally present during the summer have been cancelled,
notably on July 14.
What could have been the tipping points for this movement to gain
momentum and be joined by other struggles?
These riots were a little better perceived than those of 2005, because
there was a general anger after the demonstrations on pensions and
Sainte Soline, which can help to better understand this movement.
For there to be a connection, forces are needed, but the revolutionary
movement no longer exists. The first phase would be to create a link,
but relatively few activists live in these working-class neighborhoods.
With the yellow vests, there was no need for revolutionary organizations
to create these links, it happened quite naturally on the roundabouts.
There was a social explosion with a speech and demands among the GJ. A
fairly political movement and bearer of projects, which temporarily put
the cogs of the state in difficulty and managed to get 7 billion while
the state coffers were supposedly empty. Most of the parties and union
organizations refused to analyze the GJ as a political revolt.
Participating in a riot is part of the culture of young people in the
neighborhood. They defend their territories, it is anger expressed in
actions. Young people say "there are no slogans, we just act", but it is
not just anger, the message is clear, a guy is getting killed, we have
to react so that the next one is not me. And we are tired of being
victims of this increasingly racist police.
Working-class neighborhoods are more often stigmatized, especially
during Covid, and more recently for the defense of terrorism because of
support for Palestine and at the time of the Olympic Games, there was a
lot of repression, searches and house arrests.
But the inhabitants of working-class neighborhoods also participate in
the struggles, notably in the mobilizations for Palestine; there are
many people from the neighborhoods and few political organizations.
If the left had made immigrants vote as it had promised in 81,
politicians would care more about the inhabitants of the suburbs. During
the strike at Talbot in June and July 1982, in addition to wage demands
and improved working conditions, skilled workers of immigrant origin
fought for their union freedoms. The Mauroy government (socialist)
denounced them as being manipulated by Islamists, to discredit their
struggles and demands.
Since then, the Islamists have taken up a lot of space, and the dealers
regulate the economy and regulate the neighborhoods, it is one of the
cogs of the system.
The targets were also clear in the 93 all the companies in the free zone
burned down. Many public institutions and banks were attacked. And if
the school burns down it is perhaps because it is raining in the
classrooms. The school is also one of the places of social
discrimination and reproduction of the dominant ideology. And it also
serves as a daycare, to get parents back to work, as we saw during Covid.
And after?
These events have had a strong impact on people and minds. There were
discussions between young people and other residents in many
neighborhoods after the riots.
It is a continuation of other movements. All actions, whether
ecological, riots, GJ, anti-pension, feed off each other. A wealth is
created, and something remains, it is added to what happened before. For
example, the demonstrations after the yellow vests were modeled, took
the same form as that of the GJ.
For the moment these different movements do not really look at each
other, they remain very separate. It is our job to create links. We
could have helped them on the question of repression, it was an
opportunity to bring a clear political point of view by showing
solidarity and saying that we are right to revolt, that the riot is
legitimate.
The Yellow Vests are not joining the demonstrations of support, probably
because of the trauma caused by the enormous police repression still
underway. There are still trials and the families are affected by the
injured. They are not putting themselves forward, even if some are still
in the movements. It is a missed opportunity, people did not come out,
they left the kids all alone.
The media sets the pace and delivers a discourse. We see this in the
difference in treatment with the farmers' riots that went as far as Paris.
There is another component missing, something stronger than the riot.
The form was liked, being where the cops are not, but it is difficult to
continue when the government sends tanks against the rioters.
We are not just in solidarity, but we fight to change the world for us
too, where we are. It was complicated to mobilize even in the union
organizations.
There were calls to go to court where the young people were appearing
immediately, but they were well guarded. In addition, the majority were
summoned to the juvenile court, therefore without an audience. In
Bobigny, you had to know in which room the trial was taking place in
order to be able to enter, and since the clerks were also on strike,
there was no indication of the room. However, there were many more
people at the trials than in 2005.
Some anti-repression groups spend more time dealing with the left and
have missed the riots. Nevertheless, an anti-repression and anti-racist
fund has been created.
On the relationship to the image , we keep saying that we should not
film during demonstrations or other things, while we see that the
movement began thanks to the video of Nahel's death and that perhaps
without this shocking video, nothing would have happened. Can't the
videos serve as an archive of what happened, scenes of looting, cop
attacks, the jubilation...? So as not to forget.
Odile
Notes
1- see box
2- Immigration and Suburbs Movement
3- FASTI Federation of ASTI- Associations of Solidarity with All Immigrants.
GISTI Information and Support Group for Immigrants
The film Athena
Athena is a French film released on Netflix in 2022 and directed by
Romain Gavras. Grandson of an Algerian rifleman, Abdel is a young
lieutenant in the French army, engaged in Mali. He returns following the
death of his youngest brother Idir, apparently deceased as a result of a
police blunder. Abdel finds his family torn apart, between the desire
for revenge of his little brother Karim and the business in peril of his
big brother dealer Moktar, he tries to calm the tensions. Minute by
minute, the Athena city plunges into chaos, then the situation
degenerates into civil war throughout France... The end of the film
reveals that a small far-right group staged the fake police blunder that
cost Idir his life.
http://oclibertaire.lautre.net/spip.php?article4261
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Geen opmerkingen:
Een reactie posten