The Platform for the Organization of Libertarian Communists is a foundational text of libertarian communism. Our activist network has decided to publish this century-old text in four parts, with commentary. The constructive section begins " on the first day of the social revolution ." This is no coincidence. This question is at the heart of the problems faced by revolutionary anarchists, as opposed to individualists.
1. The problem of the first day of the social revolutionCommentary : Asking about the first day of the revolution is a point that fundamentally differentiates anarchist theory from Leninism. The Platform asserts, in the context of Tsarist Russia, that "the very first task of the social revolution is to destroy the statist edifice of capitalist society." This presentation may seem reductive today if it is isolated from what happened before and what will happen afterward.
The "crucial moment" represented by "the victory of the workers over the current capitalist and bourgeois system and its representatives" cannot occur without slow preparation, without the gradual construction of counter-powers within capitalist society. In times of major capitalist crisis, their coordination can lead to a dual power structure. And as soon as a collapse of the state is achieved, anarchists propose replacing the state with this newly emerged power, and certainly not doing what the Bolsheviks did-that is, restoring the machinery of the state.
But we do not know how the revolutionary process will unfold. However, we will fight against any authoritarian logic that runs counter to the aspirations of the masses for democracy.
The fundamental goal of the world of work in struggle is the foundation, by means of revolution, of a free, egalitarian communist society, founded on the principle: " From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs ."
However, this society will not come about on its own, solely through the force of social upheaval. Its realization will unfold as a more or less prolonged social-revolutionary process, guided by the organized forces of victorious labor along a predetermined path.
Our task is to point out this path now, to formulate the positive and concrete problems that will confront workers from the very first day of the social revolution. The fate of this revolution itself will depend on their proper resolution.
It goes without saying that the construction of the new society will only be possible after the victory of the workers over the current capitalist and bourgeois system and its representatives. It is impossible to begin building a new economy and new social relations as long as the power of the state defending the system of slavery has not been broken, as long as the workers and peasants have not taken control, within a revolutionary framework, of the industrial and agricultural economy of the country.
Therefore, the very first task of the social revolution is to destroy the statist edifice of capitalist society, to deprive the bourgeoisie and, in general, all socially privileged elements of the means of power, and to establish everywhere the will of the rebellious proletariat, expressed in the fundamental principles of the social revolution. This destructive and combative aspect of the revolution will only clear the way for the positive tasks that constitute the meaning and essence of the social revolution.
The tasks are as follows:
The solution, in the libertarian communist sense, to the problem of the country's industrial production.
The solution to the agrarian problem lies in the same direction.
The solution to the problem of consumption (supply).
2. Production
Comment : Describing the reorganization of production within libertarian communist society in so few words was a daunting task. The result schematically corresponds to the core ideas of libertarian communism. Obviously, social structures have changed profoundly in a century. Obviously, the ecological crisis is reshuffling many cards. Therefore, we would not describe the reorganization of production in the same way. But the essential points, in the context of writing this text, are already present!
Taking into account that the country's industry is the result of the efforts of several generations of workers, and that the various branches of industry are closely linked together, we regard all current production as a single workshop of producers, belonging to all workers as a whole, and to no one in particular.
The country's productive mechanism is comprehensive and belongs to the entire working class. This principle determines the character and form of the new production. It will also be comprehensive and common, in the sense that the products made by the workers will belong to everyone. These products, of whatever category, will constitute the general supply base for the workers, where every participant in the new production will receive everything they need, on an equal basis for all.
The new production system will completely eliminate wage labor and exploitation in all their forms, and establish in their place the principle of fraternal and solidarity-based collaboration among workers.
The middle class, which in modern capitalist society performs intermediate and unproductive functions-commerce and the like-as well as the bourgeoisie, must participate in the new production under the same conditions as all other workers. Otherwise, these classes will exclude themselves from the working class.
There will be no bosses, be it the entrepreneur, the landlord, or the state-owner (as is the case today in the Bolshevik state). In the new production system, the organizing functions will pass to administrative bodies created specifically for this purpose by the working masses: workers' soviets, factory committees, or workers' administrations of enterprises and factories. These bodies, linked together at the commune, district, and then nationwide levels, will form communal, district, and finally general and federal institutions for managing production. Appointed by the masses and constantly under their control and influence, all these bodies will be continually renewed and will thus realize the idea of genuine mass self-management.
Unified production, whose means and products belong to all, having replaced wage labor with the principle of fraternal collaboration and having established equal rights for all producers, production carried out by workers' management bodies, elected by the masses; this is the first step taken on the path to the realization of libertarian communism.
3. Consumption
Comment : This paragraph should be read in light of the economic problems faced by the Russian Revolution from its very beginning. The Platform sought an alternative to Bolshevik policy, in which the party dictated the quantities of agricultural products that peasants were required to supply. Such a policy created a profound rift with the rural world. However, the peasantry in Western countries has changed significantly. The initial solutions proposed here are largely irrelevant to contemporary France.
This problem will arise in the revolution in two ways:
the principle of consumer product research
the principle of their distribution
Regarding the distribution of consumer goods, the solutions will depend primarily on the quantity of products available, the principle of conformity to purpose, etc.
The social revolution, undertaking the reconstruction of the entire existing social order, assumes the responsibility of providing for everyone's basic needs. The sole exception is the group of non-workers-those who refuse to participate in the new production for counter-revolutionary reasons. But, generally speaking, and with the exception of this latter category, the needs of the entire population within the territory of the social revolution are met by the general consumption reserve. In cases where the quantity of goods is insufficient, it is distributed according to the principle of greatest urgency: that is to say, first and foremost to children, the sick, and working-class families.
A much more difficult problem will be the organization of the consumption fund itself.
Undoubtedly, in the early days of the revolution, the cities will not have all the essential goods needed to sustain the entire population. At the same time, the peasantry will have an abundance of the goods that the cities will lack.
Libertarian communists cannot doubt the mutual nature of the relationship between the city and the working countryside. They believe that social revolution can only be achieved through the joint efforts of workers and peasants. Consequently, the solution to the problem of consumption within the social revolution will only be possible through close revolutionary collaboration between these two categories of workers.
To establish this collaboration, the urban working class, having taken production into its own hands, must immediately consider the vital needs of the countryside and strive to provide everyday consumer goods, as well as the means and tools for collective agricultural cultivation. The acts of solidarity shown by the workers toward the needs of the peasants will elicit the same response from the latter, who, in turn, will collectively supply the cities with the products of rural labor, first and foremost food.
Workers' and peasants' cooperatives will be the first bodies to ensure the food and economic supplies needed by towns and villages. Later entrusted with more important and consistent functions, notably providing everything necessary to ensure and develop the economic and social life of workers and peasants, these cooperatives will thereby be transformed into permanent bodies for supplying towns and villages.
This solution to the problem of permanent supply will enable the proletariat to create a permanent supply fund, which will have a favorable and decisive impact on the fate of all new production.
4. The earth
Comment : This point is obviously complementary to the previous one and is practically as " dated ." We fundamentally recognize ourselves in its logic. This logic remains entirely valid. But this text is primarily a response adapted to the realities of peasant life within the Russian Revolution. It cannot, as it stands, constitute a proposal for the Western peasant world. We will need to reinvent a response adapted to today's realities.
We consider the working peasants-those who do not exploit the labor of others-and the wage-earning proletariat of the countryside to be the principal revolutionary and creative forces in the solution to the agrarian question. Their task will be to carry out the new land reorganization, in order to establish the use and exploitation of the land on communist principles.
Like industry, the land, worked and cultivated by successive generations of workers, is the product of their collective efforts. It belongs to the entire working population as a whole and to no one in particular. As the common and inalienable property of the workers, the land cannot be bought, sold, or leased; it cannot, therefore, be used as a means of exploitation by others.
The land is also a kind of communal, people's workshop where the working class produces the means of subsistence. But it is a kind of workshop where each worker (peasant) has, thanks to certain historical conditions, become accustomed to doing their own work, to carrying it out independently of other producers. While in industry, the collective method of work is essentially necessary and the only possible one, in agriculture, it is not the only one in our time. Most peasants cultivate the land using their own resources.
Consequently, when the land and the means of its cultivation pass to the peasants, without the possibility of sale or leasing, the question of the forms of their usufruct and the means of its exploitation (communally or within the family) will not immediately have a complete and definitive solution, as will be the case in the industrial sector. Initially, recourse will most likely be made to both of these methods.
It will be the revolutionary peasants themselves who establish the definitive form of land use and usufruct. No external pressure is possible on this matter.
However, since we believe that only the communist society, in whose name the social revolution will be made, will liberate the workers from their situation of slavery and exploitation, and give them complete freedom and equality; since the peasants constitute the overwhelming majority of the population (about 85% in Russia) and that, consequently, the agrarian system established by the peasants will be the decisive factor in the destinies of the revolution; since, finally, the private economy in agriculture, as well as private industry, commerce, accumulation, private property and the restoration of capital, our duty will be to do, from now on, everything necessary to facilitate the solution of the agrarian question in a collective sense.
To this end we must now conduct a strong propaganda campaign among the peasants in favor of the collective agrarian economy.
The establishment of a specific Peasant Union with a libertarian tendency will greatly facilitate this task.
In this sense, technological progress will be of enormous importance, facilitating the evolution of agriculture, and also the realization of communism in the cities, especially in industry. If, in their relations with the peasantry, workers act not individually or in separate groups, but as a vast communist collective, encompassing entire branches of industry; if, moreover, they consider the vital needs of the countryside and provide each village with tools and machines for the collective cultivation of the land, along with everyday objects, this will certainly give the peasantry an impetus towards communism in agriculture.
5. The defense of the revolution
Comment : Here again, the context of the Russian Revolution is crucial to the thinking of the Platform's authors. Will a similar situation unfold during a revolution stemming from a profound ecological crisis, one that could fundamentally fracture the very idea of capitalism? We are unable to answer this question. At most, we can observe that this question is not currently a pressing issue. But when it becomes so, we can reread this text and draw inspiration from the proposed solutions, adapting them to the new situation.
The question of defending the revolution also relates to the problem of the " first day ." Essentially, the most powerful means of defending the revolution is the successful resolution of its positive problems: those of production, consumption, and land. Once these problems are justly resolved, no counter-revolutionary force will be able to alter or undermine the free regime of the workers. Nevertheless, the workers will still have to endure a severe struggle against the enemies of the revolution in order to defend and maintain its concrete existence.
The social revolution, which threatens the privileges and the very existence of the non-working classes of present-day society, will inevitably provoke, on the part of these classes, a desperate resistance which will take the form of a fierce civil war.
As the Russian experience has shown, such a civil war will last not a few months, but several years.
However welcome the workers' initial steps at the start of the revolution, the ruling classes would nevertheless retain a tremendous capacity for resistance for a long time to come. For several years, they would launch offensives against the revolution, attempting to regain the power and privileges they had been deprived of.
A large army, military technology and strategy - capital - everything will be launched against the victorious workers.
In order to preserve the gains of the revolution, they will need to create organs of defense for the revolution, to oppose the offensive of reaction with a fighting force commensurate with the magnitude of the task. In the first days of the revolution, this fighting force will be formed by all armed workers and peasants. However, this spontaneous armed force will only be effective in the initial days, before the civil war has reached its peak and the two warring sides have yet established formally organized military structures.
In a social revolution, the most critical moment is not the suppression of authority, but the one that follows, that is, when the forces of the overthrown regime launch a general offensive against the workers and when it is a matter of safeguarding the gains achieved.
The nature of this offensive, as well as the techniques and development of the civil war, will compel the workers to create determined revolutionary military contingents. The essence and fundamental principles of these formations must be determined in advance. By rejecting statist and authoritarian methods of governing the masses, we thereby reject the statist means of organizing the workers' military force-in other words, the principle of a statist army based on compulsory military service. It is the principle of volunteerism, in accordance with the fundamental tenets of libertarian communism, that must form the basis of the workers' military formations. The detachments of insurgent partisans, workers and peasants, who led the action in the Russian Revolution, can be cited as examples of such formations.
However, volunteering and partisan action should not be understood in the narrow sense of these words, that is, as a struggle of worker and peasant detachments against the local enemy, uncoordinated by a general operational plan and each acting under its own responsibility, at its own risk and peril. The actions and tactics of the peasants must be guided, in the period of their full development, by a common revolutionary strategy.
Like any war, civil war could only be successfully waged by the workers by applying the two fundamental principles of all military action: unity of plan of operations and unity of common command. The most critical moment of the revolution will be when the bourgeoisie marches against the revolution in organized forces. This critical moment will compel the workers to resort to these principles of military strategy.
In this way, given the necessities of military strategy, and also of counter-revolutionary strategy, the armed forces of the revolution will inevitably have to merge into a general revolutionary army with a common command and a common plan of operations.
The following principles will be the foundation of this army:
the class character of the army.
volunteering (any coercion will be absolutely excluded from the work of defending the revolution).
Revolutionary free discipline (self-discipline): revolutionary volunteering and self-discipline will harmonize completely together, and make the army of the revolution morally stronger than any state army.
the complete submission of the revolutionary army to the working and peasant masses, in the period of common working and peasant organizations for the whole country, placed by the masses in the leading positions of economic and social life.
In other words: the organ of defense of the revolution charged with fighting the counter-revolution, both on the open military fronts and on those of the internal civil war (the plots of the bourgeoisie, the preparations of counter-revolutionary actions, etc.), will be entirely within the jurisdiction of the productive workers' and peasant organizations, to which it will be subject, and by which it will be politically oriented.
Note . While the army itself must be built in accordance with definite libertarian communist principles, it should not be considered a principled element. It is merely a consequence of military strategy in the revolution, a strategic measure to which the workers will inevitably be led by the very process of civil war. But this measure must be addressed now. It must be carefully considered so as to avoid any irreparable setbacks in the work of protecting and defending the revolution, for delays during the days of civil war could prove detrimental to the outcome of the entire social revolution.
https://plateformecl.org/la-plateforme-darchinov-partie-constructive/
_________________________________________
Source: A-infos-en@ainfos.ca